B.A 1st Semester Political Science Unit 9 Civil Society and State Solution English Medium As Per New Syllabus to each Chapter is provided in the list of SCERT, NCERT, BA 1st Sem Political Science (Minor) Chapter 9 Question Answer English Medium/B.A First Semester Political Science Chapter 9 Question Answer are given so that you can easily search through the different Chapters and select the needs Notes of BA 1st Sem Political Science Chapter 9 Question Answer English Medium. covers all the exercise questions in NCERT, SCERT.
B.A 1st Sem Political Science Minor Unit 9 Civil Society and State
B.A 1st Semester Political Science Unit 9 Civil Society and State Solution English Medium | Guide for B.A First Semester Political Science Minor Unit 9 Also Same NCERT Solutions for B.A 1st Sem Political Science In this post we will explain to you what to try If you are a Student of English Medium then it will be very helpfull for you. NCERT/SCERT, B.A 1st Sem Political Science Chapter 9.
Unit 9 Civil Society and State
CONCEPT IN POLITICAL THEORY – III
VERY SHORT TYPE QUESTIONS & ANSWERS:
1. What is civil society in political science?
Ans: A civil society is comprised of groups or organizations working in the interest of the citizens but operating outside of the governmental and for profit sectors.
2. What are the elements of civil society?
Ans: Civil society is composed of the totality of voluntary social relationships, civic and social organizations, and institutions that form the basis of a functioning society, as distinct from the force-backed structures of a state, the commercial institutions of the market profit sectors.
3. Why is civil society important?
Ans: They fulfill important duties of checks and balances in democracies, they are able to influence the government and hold it accountable. Therefore, free and active civil societies are an indicator of a healthy participatory democracy. The charter calls on governments to guarantee and protect civil societies.
4. What are the roles of civil society?
Ans: Civil society organizations (CSOs) can play an important role in enhancing transparency and good governance in developing countries by contributing to increased public debate on issues surrounding the formulation and implementation of government budgets as well as in supporting greater transparency of public revenues.
5. Why do we need civil society?
Ans: Civil society organisations have an essential role as watchdogs of Governmental institutions. They follow the political processes alertly and interfere where needed. This is how they help ensure that defects are revealed. But while it is necessary to point out problems, solutions are needed too.
6. What does civil society do?
Ans: The Role of Civil Society & NGOs. Civil society and nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) have the power to influence individual behaviour and the institutions that are involved in healthy diet and physical activity promotion.
7. What is a civil society group?
Ans: A civil society organization is a group of people which operates in the community, in a way that is distinct from both government and business, Please see: Civil society. Non-governmental organization. Social movement organization.
8. What is state according to Marxist?
Ans: According to Marx, every state is a class dictatorship. For Marx, the basic units of society, and the principal agents of change in human history are social classes, which are defined by their role in human production. Moreover, in every class-divided society, one or more of these classes rules the other classes.
9. What are the main ideas of Karl Marx’s theory?
Ans: Marx’s ideas have been thought of as responsible for socialist revolutions (like the Russian Revolution). Marx’s most popular theory was his ‘materialism’. He believed that religion, morality, social structures and other things are all rooted in economics. In his later life he was more tolerant of religion.
10. What is the goal of Marxism?
Ans: The aim of Marxism is to force upon the laborers in society an awareness of their exploitation by the bourgeoisie, the managerial class. Once the people become aware of this exploitation, they will be in the position to overthrow the oppressors and bring about a new type of society.
11. What is the meaning of patriarchal society?
Ans: A patriarchal social system can be defined as a system where men are in authority over women in all aspects of society. In modern American culture and society, the idea of patriarchy is not as accepted or practiced as it once was decades ago.
12. What is an example of a patriarchy?
Ans: An example of a patriarchy society is where men hold the control and make all the rules and women stay home and care for the kids. An example of a patriarchy is when the family name comes from the man in the family.
13. How does a patriarchal society work?
Ans: Patriarchy is a social system in which males hold primary power and predominate in roles of political leadership, moral authority, social privilege and control of property. Some patriarchal societies are also patrilineal, meaning that property and title are inherited by the male lineage.
14. How Civil society is composed?
Ans: Civil society is composed of the totality of voluntary social relationships, civic and social organizations, and institutions that form the basis of a functioning society, as distinct from the force-backed structures of a state (regardless of that state’s political system), the commercial institutions of the market.
15. What is the difference between the state of nature and civil society?
Ans: A state of nature is when there is no laws or controls, and life would be short, poor, and in solitude. Life in a civil society would have laws, political parties, justice, and a government.
SHORT TYPE QUESTIONS & ANSWERS:
1. What are the major weaknesses of Marxism?
Ans: Max Lerner has pointed out six main errors of Marxian perspective of state and politics.
These are:
(i) An underestimation of the strength of capitalism.
(ii) An overestimation of the revolutionary character of the protectorate.
(iii) An underestimation of the strength of the middleless and the misreckoning of its direction.
(iv) An underestimation of the strength of nationalism and national unity.
(v) A faulty theory of human nature of politics.
(vi) Misreckoning of proletarian dictatorship.
2. Write the main features of the classical liberal view of the nature of state.
Ans: The main features of the classical liberal view of the nature of state are as follows:
(i) State is the creation of human will: According to Hobbes and Locke, initially people live in a pre-historic state of nature. Later on the state was formed by them through a voluntary social contact. As such state originated as an agency or an organisation. A machine created by man for satisfying some of his needs. It is an artificial institution.
(ii) State as a means for protection of natural rights: State was created by men for the protection of the rights of life, liberty and property of the individual. It acts only as an agency or organisation of the people
(iii) Protection function of state: The primary function of the state is to provide protection from external attacks as well as internal disorders It acts for providing protection to the life, liberty and property of the people.
(iv) Individual more important than state: Since state is the creation of man, its basis is human will. It can never be superior to its creator, i.e. individual.
(v) State is a means: The state is a means to an end, the end being the individual state is to serve the security needs of the individual.
(vi) State is a necessary evil: Classical liberal view of the state: State is a necessary evil because it is needed for providing protection to the life, liberty and property of the individual. Evil because its laws and actions always act as limitations upon individual rights and liberty.
(vii) Society is a collection of individual: Social development means development of the individual who compose the society. Individual is the centre of all political life. He is fully capable of developing himself.
(viii) State is basically a negative functioning state: It has little role in the economic role of the society. Unrestrained economic freedom, and free competition is essential for economic progress.
3. What is Marxist perspective of state?
Ans: Marxian perspective offers a view of state, government, society and man which is totally different from the liberal perspective of the state.
regards state as an instrument of exploitation in the hands of the rich ehaves’ by which they exploit the poori.e. have nots. The government of the state is regarded as the handiwork of the rich, which uses state power for serving their interest as well as for exploiting the poor. Society is viewed as a set of two economic classes the class of haves which owns the means of production or the rich, and the class of have nots or the poor which sell labour for livelihood. Man is regarded by the Marxian view as an economic man always engaged in the process of his material needs.
Marxian perspective offers a view of the state on the basis of the laws of social development as explained by Karl Marx.
Marxian perspective seeks to analyse state and politics on the basis of three philosophical doctrines.
(i) Historical Materialism.
(ii) Economic Determination.
(iii) Class Struggle.
6. Explain the Liberal perspective and Marxist perspective of the state.
Ans: Against the liberal view of state and politics as natural social institutions, the Marxist adopt a class view of state and politics. The liberal view regards state as the means for resolving conflict. The Marxian view on the other hand, regards state as the manifestation of class struggle which upholds and perpetuates the power of the ‘haves’ and ‘have-nots’. Liberalism holds that struggle for power among groups is the case of all politics in all societies. Marxian view conceives of an ideal society free from class struggle, and the emergence of a classless and stateless society.
The former accepts peaceful resolution of conflict through peaceful reconciliations on the basis of the authoritative allocation of valves, i.e. through the making and implementation of laws, policies, and rules by the state for the whole society. Marxian view advocates a revolutionary over through of the bourgeoise state and its associates, which is to be followed by the withering away of the state.
LONG TYPE QUESTIONS & ANSWERS:
1. What do you mean the Marxian perspective of the state. Explain the main features of Marxian perspective of state.
Ans: Marxian perspective offers a view of state, government, society and man which is totally different from the liberal perspective of the state, It regards state as an instrument of exploitation in the hands of the rich i.e. haves’ by which they exploit the poor i.e. have nots. The government of the state is regarded as the handiwork of the rich, which uses state power for serving their interest as well as for exploiting the poor.
Society is viewed as a set of two economic classes – the class of haves which owns the means of production or the rich, and the class of have-nots or the poor which sell labour for livelihood. Man is regarded by the Marxian view as an economic man always engaged in the process of his material needs.
Marxian perspective offers a view of the state on the basis of the laws of social development as explained by Karl Marx.
Marxian perspective seeks to analyse state and politics on the basis of three philosophical doctrines.
(i) Historical Materialism.
(ii) Economic Determination.
(iii) Class Struggle.
The main features of Marxian perspective of state are as follows:
(i) Marx regards state is an organised institution of the rich for exploiting the poor.
(ii) State is neither natural nor an essential institution.
(iii) Marxian view holds that all political relations in the state are dependent upon economic relation.
(iv) Since politics has its roots in economies, the study of politics can be done only on the basis of the study of economic relations.
(v) The economic relation which constitute the fundamental structure of society, has relations between the economic classes – i.e. ‘haves’ and ‘have-nots’.
(vi) The conflict between the bourgeoise and the workers is the core of politics.
(vii) The essence of man is sociality and man losses humanity without it. Man must be understood in the totality of his social relations.
(viii) Society is a ever-growing and ever-evolving system. Its final form of evolution is destined to be a classless and stateless society.
(ix) The evolution of society get manifested through the eternally present class struggle between the ‘haves’ and ‘have-nots’.
(x) Class struggle between the ‘haves’ and ‘have-nots’ determines the working of state.
(xi) Marxian perspective advocates revolution as the means of political change. It stands for dictatorship of the proletariat for final liquidation of capitalism.
(xii) Marxism regards the establishment of classless and stateless society as the final aim of social development.
9. Give a critical appraisal to the Marxist theory of state.
Ans: The Marxist theory of the nature and functions of state proceeds on two basic assumptions.
(a) The state wherever it exists, is an instrument of the dominant economic class, not of the entire society, and
(b) The state, so long it exists, is an instrument of repression and exploitation of the dependent class.
The critics have, however, pointed to some inadequacies of this framework.
Those are as follow:
(i) No sharp division of society into class: The critics of Marxian argue that no where in society sharply divided into two economic classes-the haves and have-nots as the Marxist hold.
They alleges that, for the economic point of view between the upper and lower classes these is a very large middle class and constant vertical social mobility through various strata. The Marxist theory of the elimination of the middle class with the advance of capitalism does not seem anywhere near realization. On the contrary, the size of the middle class has been increasing with the advance of capitalism.
(ii) Changing nature of capitalism: The critics also argue that the character of capitalism itself has undergone a fundamental transformation since the time of Marx, and that the Marxian analysis of the functions of the state in capitalist society is, therefore, no longer valid. This argument refers to several factors, such as:
(a) increasing replacement of individual ownership by corporate ownership dispersed over thousands of shareholders.
(b) actual shift of power from the owners industry to the professional, managerial classes and the technocrates etc. and
(c) adoption of the model of the welfare state by most capitalist states, thus bridging the gap between the rich and the poor.
(iii) Inequalities power is socialist state: The critics of Marxism points out that the will to power, to suppress the antagonist and to secure larger advantages for oneself is so universal and so strong that even after the socialisation of the means of production when wide disparities in personal wealth are eliminated, disparities in power continue to govern the behaviour of man in society.
(iv) Shift focus from base to super structure: Classical Marxism holds that politics, religion, morals, etc. prevailing in any society at any point of time, are essentially shaped by the prevailing mode of production. Thus, the mode of production is treated as the base or structure while politics, religion, etc. are treated the super structure. The critics of Marxism believe that this is not validated by experience.
Conclusion: However, in spite of some theoretical shortcomings, the establishment of socialist societies on the Marxist model over a large part of the world led to immense development of material resources for human satisfaction. According to social needs, not for the private profit of a handful of capitalists accompanied by tremendous of development of science and technology for stepping up production, which secure freedom from want and freedom from ignorance.
10. Define state? Discuss the difference between state and government.
Ans: State is a territory with certain elements comprising population and International recognition. Government is an element of the state. It is based politically either by elected or selected.
The following are the differences between the state and government:
Firstly: The state is a permanent institution where as government is temporary.
Secondly: The state has sovereign power, but the government has no sovereign power.
Thirdly: State is formed with some population in a territory where those government concerned is formed by the representatives of the people.
Fourthly: people have no right to go against the state, but they have right to do so against the government.
Fifthly: The nature of the state is same throughout the word but government may be different state to state.
11. Discuss the main theories regarding nature of state.
Ans: Political science studies state and defines it as the community of numerous persons, permanently occupying a different territory, possessing an organised government which is the instrument for the exercise of the sovereignty of the state.
Several theories were propounded for exploiting the nature of state and the relationship between the individual and state.
(i) The organic theory: The organic theory holds that the state is an organism and the individuals are the parts of the state. In an organism parts are parts of the whole. These develop only as parts of the organism. All the parts stand fully integrated with the whole organism is the whole. It is prior to its parts. It is the end and its parts are the means. Likewise state is also an organism. State is the whole. It is the end, individual are its parts.
State is prior to the individual. The development of the individuals is possible only as parts of the state. They can live and develop only in the state. The organic theory gives total primacy to the state and makes the individuals dependents on the state. It is an extreme theory as it gives all importance to the state.
(ii) The mechanistic theory: As against the organic theory, the machine view or the mechanistic theory holds that state is a machine Like any other machine, state is created by the individuals for satisfying their needs. State is the means, individuals the end. Every machine is made by men for satisfying their needs. Likewise the purpose of the state is to serve the ends or needs of the individual. The machine theory gives all importance to the individual. It is again an extreme theory as it gives all importance to the individual.
(iii) Justice Theory: The justice theory or the Judicial view of the state advocates the view that state is a legal personality like a corporation or company organised under law. “State is a corporation and creation of law, an artificial personality with sovereign legal powers and functions,” This theory gives importance to law and views the state as a legal personality.
(iv) Class Theory: State is a class institution is advocated by Karl Marx and his followers. It is held that state is a class institution that created by the rich for serving as the instrument of their will. It is an institution of the rich for exploiting the poor. It is neither natural nor permanent and nor even a useful institution. It is an instrument of exploitation and coercion in the hands of the rich for exploiting the poor. Class theory stands for the end of the state and advocates the need for securing a classless and stateless society.
12. Explain the liberal perspective of the nature of state.
Ans: Liberal perspective of the nature of state can be discussed in two parts:
(a) The classical Liberal Individualistic view and
(b) The modern Liberal Democratic view.
(a) The Classical Liberal (Individualistic) view of Nature of state: In its traditional form the liberal perspective regards the state as a machine and a creation of human will. State is viewed as an instrument for the protection of life, liberty and property of the individual through the maintenance of law and order. It acts for the dispensation of justice in cases of disputes among the people. The social contractualists like. Hobbes and Locke, the utilitarians like Bentham and J. S. Mill any several others advocated that the state was a mere means to the end.
It was an agency or organization entrusted with the function of providing security to the people from external and internal attacks and disorders. Classical liberal view of the nature of state upholds the ideology of individualisms which regards the state as a necessary evil and individual as the centre of all social life and activity.
The main features of classical liberal view of the nature of state are as follows:
(i) State is the creation of human will.
(ii) State as a means for protection of natural rights.
(iii) Protection functions of state.
(iv) Individual more important than state.
(v) State is a means.
(vi) State is a necessary evil.
(vii) Society is a collection of individuals.
(viii) State is basically a negative functioning state.
The classical view holds that the state is a machine. It is the creation of human will; its purpose is to provide protection to the life, liberty and property of the people. It is a sovereign law-making agency or organisation created by human will; it is a negative functioning state with little role in the economic life of the society and that it is a necessary evil, a police state or laisses fair state. Classical liberal individualistic view gives all importance to the individual and regards the state as a machine de signed by the individual for satisfying his needs and interests.
(b) Modern liberal perspective of state: Positive Liberation: Modern liberal view of the nature of state regards it as a natural and positive institution. Primary function of the state is not only the maintenance of law and order and securing of protection but also the promotion of social welfare, social cohesion, national integration, and orderly social development. It is a natural institution and welfare state. It is to serve the common good or general interest of the society as a whole. Positive liberalism promotes the concept of welfare state and holds that the function of the state is to promote the welfare of its citizens and not merely to protect the life and property of the citizens.
This view regards politics as a group activity, natural and necessary for the resolution of conflict and for recurring a tolerable harmony in society Politics is an open and free struggle for power among the people organised in their groups. It is a group phenomenon in which each group seeks to secure the power to make and implement authoritative values for the whole society.
The modern liberal view holds that each individual is a social being with of his personality is the and for this purpose the state is an instrument of welfare. Individual’s life is a social life which has several dimensions-social, political, economic, religious and cultural. The state has come into existence as a natural institution. It has been the result of a gradual social evolution. It works for providing protection and securing welfare of all.
The following are the salient features of the liberal perspective of politics:
(i) State is the instrument of establishing rule of law and order in society.
(ii) Individual is the centre of all social life.
(iii) State is the sovereign institution acting for the promotion of common interest.
(v) State as the means of conflict resolution in society.
(v) Open competition, not state ownership and control, is an essential condition for promoting common good.
(vi) Less economic role and free competition essential for increased production and economic development.
(vii) Open and free struggle for power in the state is the condition for securing popular, responsive and responsible government.
(viii) Rights and freedom.
(ix) Civil liberty is essential for individual or social progress.
(x) Harmony between individual and social interests.
(xi) Modern liberal perspective of functions of state.
Liberal perspective holds that the state is a natural and essential human institution for maintaining law, order and justice in society. It acts for granting and guaranteeing socio-economic-civil-political rights and freedom to the people. Politics is a process of peaceful and orderly conflict resolution in society for securing the objectives of peace, harmony and development. It stands for free and open struggle for power among the people organised in their voluntary groups and parties.
13. What is the difference between state and Association.
Ans: The difference between state and Association are:
(a) The State has a definite territory. It may be big or small but it must have fixed boundaries. An association, on the other hand, may be limited to a small locality or it may be international in its scope. A badminton club is an example of a local association. While the Red Cross Society is an international association. Associations do not have fixed territory.
(b) Membership of the State is compulsory but that of an association is optional. A man is born in the State and cannot withdraw from the membership of the State. One can easily withdraw from the membership of any association.
(c) The membership of the State is singular. One cannot be a member of more than one State simultaneously. However, one may be the member of more than one association.
(d) The State possesses sovereignty. Its sovereignty is legally absolute and supreme. Its laws are obligatory and backed by physical force. No other associations are sovereign. They are limited organizations formed to achieve limited purposes. The State is formed with unlimited purposes. It, on the other hand represents the society as a whole. It maintains law and order and protects individuals from external aggression.
(e) The State is more or less permanent and is not easily subject to dissolution but an association may be dissolved at any time and on any ground. An association may be dissolved due to internal differences among its members or when its purposes are fulfilled. While associations are temporary, the State continues for all time to come.
(f) The State is national in character. General principle is “one nation, one State”. But an association may be local, national or international.
(g) The functions and activities of the State are wider than those of associations are. An association is created for a specific purpose.
However, the activities of the State are unlimited. The functions of the State are increasing day by day. In a welfare State, the functions of the State are innumerable. While the State is a broad and universal organisation. the associations are limited in their activities.
(h) Finally, the State is the supreme association in the society. It controls the activities of all other associations. It may impose limitations on other associations. Associations cannot go against the State. The State is like an elder brother to other associations. That is why, it is said that the State is an “association of associations”. Barker rightly observed, “The State, as a general and all embracing institution of life, must necessarily adjust the relations of associations to itself, to other associations and to their own members.”
14. What are the characteristics of the state?
Ans: The characteristics of the state are:
(a) The state is geographically identifiable with distinct boundaries. One definite geographical area belongs to one state only. The same area cannot be claimed by more than two states at a time.
(b) The state is a human organization. A state has its own population consisting of citizens and non-citizens. The state has full authority over the citizens and has to protect the entire population.
(c) The state is a legal personality. It can be sued and be sued.
(d) The authority of the state is legal. It is based on procedural rules which are more acceptable to the society than any other rule.
(e) State is abstract and government is its concrete form. It acts through the government which may be of different forms.
(f) Sovereignty is just like the soul of the state. Without sovereignty, the identity of the state will be lost.
(g) State is internally supreme over the individuals and associations and externally independent and equal with other states.
15. What role was played by Religion in the process of the building up of the state.
Ans: Religion has played a vital role in the process of the building up of the state. Religion gave unity to the people both in the primitive and middle ages. As Gettle observes, “Kinship and religion were simply two aspects of the same thing. Common worship was even more essential than kinship subjecting the primitive man to authority and discipline and to develop in him a keen sense of social solidarities and cohesion.” Those outside were regarded as stranger and even as enemies. People were thus united together under the authority of the same religious sovereign. Religion appeared in the world in different forms at different stages of history.
In the very early times, the prevalent religion of mankind was animism-worship of animals, trees and stones. It was later supplemented with ancestral worship. People descending from the same ancestors were thus united together. Later, religion appeared in the form of nature worship. The Primitive men could not understand such natural phenomena as storms, thunder and lightning, or the change of seasons or the mystery of birth and death. They had implicit faith in the spirits of the nature and the spirits of the dead. They were afraid of the forces of nature. They worshipped them out of awe and reverence.
In subsequent ages, magician kings made their appearance. The magicians pretended that they could propitiate the evil spirit. Thus taking advantage of the fear, ignorance and superstition of the fellowmen, the magicians established their authority. In course of time, the magician kings gave way to priest kings. The priest kings remained popular till late in the middle ages. Religion came to be organized as a regular institution.
The Popes dominated the Christian world, the Caliphs established their authority over the Muslim world, etc. Whatever the form of religion, there is no denying the fact that religion gave unity to the people and thus virtually helped in the process of state building.
16. Write a short note on Kinship.
Ans: The social instinct of man was supplemented by kinship or blood relationship. The earliest human organizations were based on kinship or blood relationship. Blood relationship was the most important bond of union among the primitive people. It knit together clans and groups and gave them unity and cohesion. The people who had their origin in a common ancestor lived together in separate social units. Those who could not establish any blood relationship were treated as enemies. Even today, we see various castes and sub-castes.
In sociological sense they have their origin in common ancestor and caste is still known by the name of that original ancestor. The patriarch of the head of the family forms the government with sovereign power over its members. Hence the justification of Aristotle’s remark “State is the magnified image of the family.
“The original family gradually expanded and developed into a household or a ‘gen’. The gens by further multiplications developed into clans and clans united to form tribes. The bond throughout was kinship and persons unconnected by blood relationship could not become members of a tribe unless as a special case one was admitted by adoption. In a tribe, the head of the oldest or the strongest clan became the ruler generally called the ‘Chief and his name became the symbol of ‘kinship. ‘In the words of MacIver, “Kinship created society and society at length created the state.
17. Short Note:
(a) Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679)
Ans: Thomas Hobbes, an English thinker, was of the opinion that society came into being as a means for the protection of men against the consequences of their own nature.
Man in the state of nature was in perpetual conflict with his neighbours on account of his essentially selfish nature. To quote Hobbes, the life of man was “solitary poor, nasty, brutish and short”. Every man was an enemy to every other man.
Hobbes in his book “Leviathan” has made it clear that man in the state of nature was not at all social. According to him; man found “nothing but grief in the company of his fellows”- all being almost equally “selfish self. seeking, cunning, egoistic, brutal arid aggressive”. Thus, men in the state of nature were like hungry wolves each ready to pounce on the other with all its ferocity.
Since the conditions in the state of nature were intolerable and men longed for peace, the people entered into a kind of social contract to ensure for themselves security and certainty of life and properly.
By mutual agreement they decided to surrender their natural rights into the hands of a few or one with authority to command. The covenant or agreement was of each with all and of all with each. The covenant was,
of course, a social contract and a governmental contract. The contract became binding on the whole community as a perpetual social bond. Thus, in order to protect himself against the evil consequences of his own nature man organized himself in society in order to live in peace with all.
(b) John Locke (1632-1704)
Ans: John Locke, another English political philosopher, believed that man in the state of nature was enjoying an ideal liberty, free from all sorts of rules and regulations.
The state of nature was a state of “peace, goodwill, mutual assistance, and preservation”. But there was no recognised system of law and justice. Hence his peaceful life was often upset by the “corruption and viciousness of degenerate men”. Man was forced to face such an “ill condition”.
John Locke, the British writer who supported the cause of limited monarchy in England, maintained in his “On Civil Government” that the “ill condition” in which men were forced to live was “full of fears and continual dangers”. In order to escape from this and to gain certainty and security men made a contract to enter into civil society or the state. This contract Locke called ‘social contract’. This contract put an end to the state of nature and substituted it by civil society. The social contract was no more than a surrender of certain rights and powers so that man’s remaining rights would be protected and preserved.
The contract was for limited and specific purposes, and what was given up or surrendered to the whole community and not to a man or to an assembly of men (as Hobbes said). Locke made it clear that the social contract later on contributed to governmental control.
The governmental contract was made by the society when it established a government and selected a ruler to remove the inconveniences of “ill-condition”.
(c) Jean Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778)
Ans: J.J. Rousseau, the French writer of the 18th century in his famous book “The Social Contract” (1762) wrote that man in the state of nature was a ‘noble savage’ who led a life of “primitive simplicity and idyllic happiness”. He was independent, contented, self-sufficient healthy, fearless. and good It was only primitive instinct and sympathy which united him with others He knew neither right nor wrong and was free from all notions of virtu and vice. Man enjoyed a pure, unsophisticated, innocent life of perfect freedom and equality in the state of nature, Rousseau argued. Men were free from the influence of civilization, and sought their own happiness uncontrolled by social laws and social institutions.
But these conditions did not last long. Population increased and reason was dawned. Simplicity and idyllic happiness disappeared. Families were established, institution of properly emerged and human equality was ended Man began to think in terms of ‘mine’ and ‘thing’. Difference between stronger and weaker, rich and poor, arose.
18. What do you understand the Patriarchal Theory. Explain briefly.
Ans: Sir Henry Maine is the chief advocate of the patriarchal theory. He defines it as theory of the origin of society in separate families, held together by the authority and protection of the eldest male descendant The patriarchal theory traces the origin of the state in a patriarchal family, A patriarchal family is one in which descent is traced through males Father or patriarch occupies a dominant position in the family. All the members of the family pay due homage to him. His authority is recognized by all of them. A patriarchal family, according to this theory is the most ancient social organization.
The primitive men were organized in patriarchal families. Such a family began to expand by the process of marriages and remarriages. It developed into ‘Gen’ or a household. A Gen expanded into a ‘Clan’. A clan expanded into a ‘Tribe’. All the members of the tribes were united by a sort of blood relationship. The tribes united by ties of blood acted together for common purposes particularly in defending themselves against the aggression of other tribes. This also necessitated the recognition of some common authority which could maintain discipline among the tribes.
The influential member of the tribe came to be known as the tribal chief. A combination of the various tribes resulted in a commonwealth and a commonwealth was a full fledged state. Maine traces the origin of the state in the following words: “The elementary Soup is the family connected by the common subjection to the highest male ascendant. The aggregation of families forms the Gens or the houses.
The aggregation of houses makes the tribe. The aggregation of the tribes constitute the commonwealth. According to Edward Jenks the patriarchal society which according to this theory was the foundation of modern state was characterized by three features, viz., male kinship, permanent marriages and paternal authority In other words the descent was traced through the father and not the mother. Permanent marriage implied that one man was permanently married to one or more women as patriarchal society allowed – both monogamy and polygamy. The eldest male member of the family.
The theory also found its support, first of all, at the hands of Aristotle He held that “Just as men and women unite to form families, so many families unite to form villages and the union of many villages forms the state which is a self-supporting unit.”
The theory is further supported by historical evidence and scriptural accounts. The ancient Jews were a nation of twelve tribes which trace their origin to the first father Jacob.
Notes of B.A First Semester Political Science Unit 9 | B.A 1st Sem Political Science Minor Notes In this post we will explain to you B.A 1st Sem Political Science Chapter 9 Question Answer | BA 1st Sem Political Science Question Answer Unit 9 If you are a Student of English Medium then it will be very helpfull for you.
Note- If you find any mistakes in this UNIT, please let us know or correct them yourself. Thank you.